Damon still answered it correctly.

Sabrina knew what his answer would be. But she still feigned surprise.

Seeing that Sabrina believed Damon, Tyrone took the phone from her and told Damon, “I have to hang up now. Let's talk about it some other time when I'm free."

Ending the call and pocketing the phone, Tyrone looked at Sabrina expectantly. "Sabrina, you believe me now, right?"

Sabrina regarded Tyrone calmly and responded, "Well, I believe you."