Ariana was surprised by his response and her eyes widened. She asked, "If you know that, why do you still treat her so well? Is it just because she was Marley's best friend?"

Theodore's face darkened when he heard the name "Marley". Much like the moment back at the Anderson family's residence when he learned from Helen that Ariana went into Marley's room, he was unable to mask his terrible expression.

As Ariana's eyes welled up, she struggled to keep the quiver out of her voice as she asked, 'Who is Marley? Do you care about her a lot? Why is her room still on the fourth floor? And what do you think of me?”

Ariana hoped for more answers from Theodore, but he remained silent.

"So, she truly matters to you.” Ariana spoke softly, almost as if she was mocking herself.