Amidst the chaos, Marge's voice of reason surfaced. "Hold on. I've been swamped with another project this season and haven't kept up with the show. What's going on? I don't recall this guy being introduced as a guest?”

Ariana decided to come clean. Realizing there was no way around it she confessed. “Guys, that man is actually Theodore."

The group exploded in shock, prompting Ariana to recount the entire story once more, detailing Theodore's another identity as Holden and his memory loss following a car accident.

As Ariana finished her explanation, Sarah expressed her astonishment with a barrage of shocked emojis, setting off a chorus of similar reactions from the others. Then, a flurry of voice messages followed.

“How is this even possible? Is it destiny or some sort of divine intervention?"